For
Thursday's Class: Online readings from the United Nations High Commissioner
on Refugees http://www.unhcr.ch/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/home
To locate
articles:
1. use search bar at top of UNHCR page to enter article names –
2. Must turn in notes for these readings – Bring notes to class
Notes
for Today's Discussion -- From Susan Griffin’s “The Sacrificial
Lamb” in Pornography and Silence
“If
we look closely at the portrait which the racist draws of a man or a woman of
color, or that the anti-Semite draws of the Jew, or that the pornographer draws
of a woman, we begin to see that these fantasized figures resemble one another.
For they are the creations of one mind. This is the chauvinist mind, a mind
which projects all it fears in itself onto another: a mind which defines itself
by what it hates” (160)
. . . “Over
and over again the chauvinist draws a portrait of the other which reminds us
of that part of his own mind he would deny and which he has made dark to himself.
The other has appetite and instinct. The other has a body. The other has an
emotional life which is uncontrolled. And in the wake of the denied self, the
chauvinist constructs a false self with which he identifies” (161)
- “In
the black man, the force of desire, of appetite, of wanting is played out,
and in the white woman, an awareness of vulnerability, weakness, mortality,
fear can be lived. Through the forms of these two imaginary figures the memories
of infancy and the knowledge of the body return to haunt the mind which would
erase them” (166)
-
“The chauvinist has used the idea that he is superior as a justification
to enslave and exploit the other, whom he describes as inferior” (161)
-
Desire to believe culture more powerful than nature/ mind over body
- Fear
and want construct a dilemma in his mind and he is at war with himself 167
- Minds
desire to escape the truth (of his body) 162
- Cannot
face the truth that he despises himself 162
- The
racist mind and the misogynist mind are really only one mind, a mind trying
to escape the dark, ‘feminine: self 72
-
“Almost everywhere that one finds a virulent form of racism, one also
finds an idea of traditional roles oppressive to women. This was as demonstrably
true in the American South as it was in the Third Reich, and as it always
is in reactionary political movements” (172)
- Pornography
= separate mind from body, drive emotion out; pornography ultimately punishes
sexuality 196
- Crisis
in man’s mind and ideology of pornography: pornography teaches rape.
For the violence of the mind’s feeling must b shaped. The man terrified
of himself must be given symbols through which he many continue to deny part
of himself. In the midst of his private terror, culture must give him an enemy.
(176
- “Whether
the chauvinist mind expresses itself through racist propaganda or through
pornography, its delusions are not innocent. For the mind which believes in
a delusion must ultimately face reality. And because the chauvinist desperately
needs to believe in his delusion, when he is faced with the real nature of
the world, he must act. He must force the world to resemble his delusion .
. . his body, or the reality of the other, or the force of nature, will eventually
speak to him and tell him the truth that he has buried, he is driven to reshape
the world to his madness and silence the voices he fear. Ultimately, the chauvinist
must face a crisis in his delusion; ultimately, he must be violent”
(168)
- This
structure of mind “is woven into the very language of our culture and
into all its institutions, habits, visions. The delusion shaped by this mind
is a mass delusion and touches us all” (167)
- The chauvinist
mind has always been terrified of cultural achievement in the despised other.
For to serve his delusion, he must keep nature and culture separate. Thus
he hates the idea of the educated black or the articulate woman.
- Desire
to possess that which he has denied is a part of himself 193
- On a
fundamental level, pornography is an express of self-hatred 194
- German
propagandists flooded Poland with pornography before the German army invaded
that nation. Eros = whole mind/ body, emotion, desire, feeling
From Carolyn Nordstrom’s “Visible Wars and Invisible Girls,
Shadow Industries, and the Politics of Not-Knowing”
-
In Mozambique . . . “A group of European men were making and marketing
pornographic films. Their actions came to light when the dog they were forcing
one girl to have sex with mauled her. She was unceremoniously dumped a hospital.
The doctors at the hospital were unable to save the child. The hospital staff,
and those they called in to witness the atrocity, were outraged. They petitioned
the government to treat this as a formal crime; and the government representative
were equally outraged. Yet no reports hit the presses; no formal court proceedings
took place. Officials associated with the Embassy who counted the pornographers
as countrymen stepped in to quiet the situation. Leverage was effectively
applied. The major offenders were quietly escorted out of Mozambique without
any reprisal. The crime was hushed. And the networks that existed to produce
these films was not exposed to public or judicial scrutiny. It was left intact.
This point is an important one: atrocities such as using war orphans for pornography
do not rest on a few men making a few films. They function as part of a large
transnational network of production, distribution, exploitation, and financial
gain. They represent an international industry, a multinational non-corporation,
no matter how illegal it is. . . .
- Forcing
a girl to provide physical or sexual labor involves a host of adult industries
that are often defined as legitimate; cooks to cook for the girls, landlords
who own the property where girls are forced to labor, airlines and shipping
lines, officials who arrange transport for undocumented workers internationally,
immigration officials who turn a blind eye, doctors who treat the girls.
Vendors who sell them, and so on through a host of actors and profiteers.
All of these many related enterprises are central to the existence of
child labor.
- We want
to say that violent pornographers are an aberration, an illness, not of “me”
and “you” and “us”. But “pornography is a multi-billion
dollar a year industry world wide. – the men who were making the pornography
in Mozambique came from Europe. The needed equipment, air transport, supplies
and start-up wages. They were financed and outfitted. Once in Mozambique,
they needed assistants to procure the girls and to set up filming facilities,
to feed and house all involved, and to run interface with the authorities.
They needed editing equipment and studios. They needed production facilities
to make distribution copies. And they needed people to distribute these; people
to pack and transport films to various destinations worldwide; people at those
destinations to wholesale and retail these products, and people to advertise
to potential customer, and legal consultants to keep them out of prison. This
is a complex and integrated transnational system. And as far as multinationals
go, the sex industry as a whole is one of the larger and more powerful ones
- Would we
as readily find the physical and sexual abuse of girls in war if child prostitution
did not flourish in many countries. If domestic physical and sexual violence
were not common, and commonly accepted, throughout the world? The prostitution
of children is a multi-billion dollar a year industry , which gives us some
indication of the numbers of adults who are NOT outraged a the sexual exploitation
of children.
- A review
of the 160 foreigners arrested in asia or sexual abuse of children between 1992
and 1994 showed the accused to be: 25% American, 18% German, 14% Australian,
12% British, and 6% French -- all told, 65% Western!!!